National Treasury Management Agency (NTMA) How much has the HSE paid out in compensation to patients for malpractice, including patients' families and next to kin, at Irish hospitals since 2008? And a breakdown of that spend by year and by hospital. The number and nature of all malpractice cases that resulted in a pay out to a patient or their family or next to kin in Irish hospitals since 2008 and a breakdown of those by year and by hospital. I.E How many cases of malpractice have their been since 2008 and the nature of the cases?