Department of Transport All correspondence to and from the Irish authorities in respect of the EU Commission State Aid Investigation case 31/2017 All documents relating to any verification checks by the DTTAS in respect of the application of the “pence per mile factor” in respect of all three sets of services of Bus Éireann from 1997 to date. (The state aid law provides for a claw back for 10 years prior 2007 All document withheld from the Commission that would show annually that Bus Éireann did not apportion charges on the “cost per mile factor” All document withheld from the Commission what would show annually that Bus Éireann made a net surplus (profit) Loss (deficit) in split format for Commercial